Yahoo HotJobs gives would-be job interviewees tips on how to handle “ Would-Be Interview Questions.” They give three examples:
- “If aliens landed here right now, what would you do?”
- “What did you want to be when you were 8 years old?”
- “What would your refrigerator say if it could talk?”
Clueless interviewers (most hiring managers and all HR drones) will ask these types of questions, as well as anything from the ‘Big Book of Interview Questions.’ They serve no purpose, except to give the incompetent interviewer the feeling that he is Doing Something. Here is Yahoo’s explanation of why one would ask such inane questions:
While a rare interviewer may ask these questions simply to (a) watch you squirm, many wild-card questions serve a purpose. Generally speaking, interviewers ask these questions (b) to see how well you perform under pressure and think on your feet. They also might ask wild cards (c) to break out of the routine of a typical interview in order to get a glimpse of your genuine personality.
Let’s tackle the rationale first.
- a
-
The truly sadistic interviewer is actually a good thing. The fact that he (or she) is allowed to represent the company to potential hires demonstrates that either the pervasive culture is one of extreme dysfunctionality, or they’re just idiots.
In either case, your choice is clear: find somewhere else to interview. You do not want to work for this company, unless you enjoy being dumped on every day you are there, until you finally hang yourself in the bathroom stall.
- b
-
At least the interviewer is well-meaning (we hope). Clueless, but well-meaning. The only thing this “test” does is determine how well you answer stupid questions under pressure. It has nothing to do with how well you can do the job. Then again, if the person interviewing actually knew how to determine if you could do the job, she wouldn’t be asking you dumb-ass questions, right?
Do you think your city Fire Department asks these stupid questions of its potential recruits? We know that Firemen are required to react well under pressure, as that is one of the most stressful jobs around: people’s lives depend on firefighters, and the firefighters themselves could die if they mess up (or even if they don’t).
Frankly, if a firefighter recruit could answer any of these questions, I‘d thank him for his time and move on to the next person. No, I’m kidding. I would apply whatever REAL criteria fire departments use to gauge suitability. It probably involves something like being able to actually do the job in a training environment. But, you know, that takes work on the part of the interviewer and is hard on everyone.
- c
- Yes, if you (as the interviewer) find that all your interviewees are answering your questions with ease, and it is too hard to determine who is best for the job, take heart in the fact that your interviewees at least studied for your test by buying (or downloading) one of the ‘Big Books of Interview Answers’.
If the only reason you’re “shaking things up” is because you’re—what’s the word? Oh yes—bored, then you’re an idiot interviewer.
Okay, on to the dumb-ass questions:
- 1: If aliens landed here right now, blah, blah, blah?
-
Answer: Unless you’re applying for a job with NASA, the Military (or a military contractor working with stolen alien technology), or Area-51, this is probably outside of any job description you’d ever have.
Correct answer: “Grab my gun and family and head for the hills.”
- 2: What did you want to be when you were 8 years old?
-
Obviously, this question only applies if you are 8 years old. Then it would be "What do you want to be today?" and that would be EVEN MORE STUPIDER (that’s a word, go look it up). On the other hand, if you are a shape shifter, it would probably make sense.
Correct answer: Laugh hysterically and say, “If you want to hire an 8-year-old, my kid is available once she gets her homework done after school and for a few hours on the weekend.”
- 3: What would your refrigerator say if it could talk?
-
The interviewer is basically telling you that that he has a stupid old non-technological refrigerator, probably one that must be manually defrosted every three months. In this case, you are obliged to rub it in his face.
Correct answer: Lean back in your chair, stick your hand in your pants, Ed Bundy-style, and say, “Wellsir, our refrigerator actually does talk, so I can tell you what it says. When it runs low on milk, it says, ‘Time to buy more milk!’ and when it gets low on cheese, it says, ‘The cooking unit informed me that tomorrow we are having Lasagna, but we don’t have enough mozzarella cheese. Please get some today!’”



